Skip to main content

A Brief Difference In The Attitudes Of Two Historical Identities


A poet, a painter, a novelist, an essayist, a story writer and a mystic, so many personalities when entwined into one, an historical identity takes into a form of a man, whose songs are sung as the National anthem across border.
Guess! Who is this great personality?
It is none other than first Nobel laureate of India, Ravindra Nath Tagore.






     Gandhi Ji defended idols and he used to believe people cannot follow the abstract ideas about God.
     Tagore did not agree that people were so childish. He believes that somehow accepting these types of thing without any reason or thinking will lead a man to distressful circumstances.
     Gandhi Ji was a true believer of God in its human form. He himself took many fast and used to chant Ram.
     Tagore did not believe in counting and chanting mantras on beads. In one of his poem he says,"


      Leave this chanting and singing and telling of beads! Whom dost thou worship in this lonely dark corner of a temple with doors all shut?
     Open thine eyes and see thy God is not before thee!
      He is there where the tiller is tilling the hard ground and where the pathmaker is breaking stones.
     He is with them in sun and in shower, and his garment is covered with dust.


    Gandhi Ji believed that sexual life was incompatible to moral progress of human life.  He had firm belief in celibacy and in later period of life he used to experiment on celibacy.
     Tagore did not belief on such ideas.


     According to Gandhi Ji, every person must use ‘ charakha’ at least for 30 minutes in a day.  Tagore refusal was based on the point that using charakha for 30 minutes did not make a man to think or to develop reasoning.
    Where Gandhi ji strictly opposed the western products and culture and favoured only indigenous products, Tagore remained stand on his position of the necessity of harmony of culture and benefits of western products.


     There are differences, quite significant. But both had one dream that was a happy, prosperous India and both knew it well. He was Tagore who called Gandhi JI ‘Mahatma’, (The Great Soul). However Gandhi Ji proved to a great leader and till now more famous and respected in every nook and corner of world, the mysticism and sensitivity of Tagore still prevails today in the form of his mesmerizing paintings and illuminating literature



 * Post is inspired by an article written by Amartya Sen

Comments

Durga Nandan said…
If you read the article online, can you please gimme the link?
I would love to read it. :)
Amit414@IT-BHU said…
you can read this article at http://nobelprize.org/nobel_prizes/literature/articles/sen/index.html

thanks for visiting...:)
Shruti said…
hey very nice...
informative...
btw,check out my recent 55fiction!!
Amit414@IT-BHU said…
Thanks a lot :)
I am going to just check out.. :)
Indian Pundit said…
Hi Amit

Just brilliant.

Thanks for sharing dude.

Cheers

Popular posts from this blog

Women-Empowerment (A Short Story)

Her spectacle ridden red eyes were trying to run away from the crowd as soon as possible. Every person was looking so alien, so dreadful.  Her heart was pounding so fast, it felt it could come out anytime. She closed her eyes; took a long-breath; chanted a prayer, perhaps to stabilize her trembling soul. But it was of no use. In the high decibel of the noise she had already lost her ability to hear her own words. Somewhere at some meters away she found a corner.  She moved towards the corner with her shuddering legs but alas! Her blurring eyes were proving too difficult to keep open. She fell down and in a few hours she was laying against white bed-sheet in the government hospital. She didn’t know who took her there.  She moved her eyes everywhere to search some known faces. But there was no one. Finally she closed her eyes. So how are you feeling now? She heard a male, soothing yet concerned voice, but not sure if it was for her or someone else. She opened her eyes slightly...As the ima…

LAKSHMEE- A short story (Guest Post)

Many years have passed since she left this imperfect and unjust world, but still she floats around in my memories time to time. Today I have decided to tell the story of Lakshmee as was perceived through my eyes. Lakshmee was born as a first child in a family which had seen a girl child after two generations. Although a boy would have been more welcome in this case also, Her arrival in this world was tolerated or I dare say welcomed in much better way than many of other girls had in my village. At that time you could guess by the silence and gloom at home that a girls had arrived or by noise of celebration that a boy had been born. A feast was arranged as celebration for her birth which was generally reserved for boys. Her grandfather christened her Lakshmee, consoling his son that she will bring prosperity, material and money as well as many boys to family.
She was a very lovely child with plenty of smiles and comfortable with anyone wishing to carry her in his/her arms. Since she wa…

Begging Future

Scientists believe that after a certain period especially childhood, our mind does not develop; it just gathers knowledge, makes it experiences and learns new things.Freud, the father of psychology claims that till that age, the way our mind gets shaped; it lasts for our whole life and defines our behaviour and character. So, the important point which I want to draw is that childhood is the most crucial period which decides and defines our future.
To grow a child, is an art, the most beautiful living art of existence. But unfortunately, everyone doesn’t want to reveal his art as they have never felt the joy of this art Or maybe they would have work more prior to this. So their creation is not perfect. A child needs care, love, humbleness, spontaneity; which most of people would be mistaken by fulfilment of economic needs. Well, a good school can substitute the role of parents to an extent but not completely.
In case of India where good schools and perfect parents are a distant fantasy f…